Why Most Lawncare Businesses Are Overpaying for Comp Insurance (And How to Fix It) | WIMC

May 23, 2025

See How We're Different

or call us: 866-226-4436

Why Most Lawncare Businesses Are Overpaying for Comp Insurance (And How to Fix It)

When you operate a lawncare business, managing costs effectively is essential to keeping your company competitive and profitable. One of the significant expenses that many lawncare businesses face is workers’ compensation insurance. Unfortunately, it’s an area where many owners are unknowingly overpaying. While workers’ compensation is a necessary cost for protecting both employees and business owners in case of accidents or injuries, most lawncare businesses are not optimizing their insurance premiums. Overpaying for workers' comp insurance is an issue that can drain a business's resources, affecting cash flow and profitability.

In this article, we will explore why many lawncare businesses are overpaying for workers' compensation insurance, the reasons behind this issue, and most importantly, how you can address it to save money while still providing the necessary coverage for your team.

The Complexity of Workers’ Compensation Insurance for Lawncare Businesses

Workers’ compensation insurance is designed to provide wage replacement and medical benefits to employees who are injured on the job. It’s a crucial part of your business’s risk management strategy, but it can also be complicated and expensive to navigate. For lawncare businesses, the risks are often unique. Landscaping and lawncare workers spend much of their time outdoors, operating heavy machinery and using various chemicals, which can increase the risk of injury. This means the premium for workers’ compensation insurance may be higher than other types of businesses that don’t face the same level of physical risk.

However, workers’ compensation rates are based on several factors, and many lawncare businesses don’t fully understand how these factors work. As a result, they end up paying more than they should. Factors such as your payroll, the class code assigned to your business, your safety record, and how you manage claims can all influence how much you pay for workers’ compensation insurance.

Why Most Lawncare Businesses Are Overpaying for Comp Insurance

There are several reasons why lawncare businesses are often overpaying for workers’ compensation insurance. Here are some of the primary factors contributing to inflated premiums.

Incorrect Class Codes and Misclassifications

One of the biggest reasons businesses overpay for workers’ compensation insurance is being assigned the wrong class code. Insurance companies categorize businesses based on the risks they present to their employees, and these codes are crucial in determining the premiums you will pay. Lawncare businesses are often incorrectly classified, leading to higher rates.

For example, many lawncare companies are lumped into a general construction class, which carries a much higher rate than landscaping or horticultural business codes. Landscaping, which is a much lower-risk category, has a different class code than general construction. If a lawncare business is incorrectly classified as construction, it will end up paying more than necessary.

Lack of Experience Modification Factor (EMR) Management

The Experience Modification Rate (EMR) is a critical factor in determining how much you’ll pay for workers’ comp insurance. It reflects your business’s claim history and safety record. If you’ve had frequent claims or have been involved in costly accidents, your EMR will be higher, resulting in higher insurance premiums. On the other hand, businesses with a lower EMR will pay less for their insurance.

Unfortunately, many lawncare businesses don’t understand how their EMR works and fail to manage it effectively. If your business has been penalized with a high EMR, you may be paying far more than necessary. Often, lawncare companies do not take the necessary steps to improve workplace safety, reduce accidents, and actively manage their claims, which leads to an inflated EMR and, consequently, higher premiums.

Inaccurate Payroll Reporting

Another issue that often leads to overpaying for workers' compensation insurance is inaccurate payroll reporting. Insurance premiums are partly based on the total amount of payroll for your employees, so if you inaccurately report payroll figures or misclassify employees, you could be paying much more than you should.

For instance, if you are underreporting your payroll to save money on premiums, you risk getting caught in an audit, which can result in significant fines or retroactive premium adjustments. On the other hand, overreporting payroll can lead to unnecessarily high premiums. Ensuring that your payroll is accurately reported and classifying workers correctly is essential to prevent overpaying.

Overlooking Safety Programs and Loss Prevention

Insurance companies reward businesses that prioritize safety with lower premiums. If a lawncare business does not have a robust safety program in place, they are more likely to experience workplace accidents, which can result in higher claims and increased premiums.

Many lawncare businesses overlook the importance of developing and maintaining comprehensive safety programs. A strong safety culture not only reduces the likelihood of injuries but can also improve your EMR, leading to lower insurance costs over time. Neglecting to implement effective safety protocols and fail to invest in training and protective equipment can lead to higher workers' compensation premiums and a poor safety record.

How to Fix the Problem and Lower Your Workers’ Comp Insurance Premiums

If you own a lawncare business and you’re concerned that you might be overpaying for workers' compensation insurance, there are several steps you can take to address the issue and start saving money without sacrificing the protection your employees need.

1. Get a Professional Audit of Your Insurance Policy

The first step in correcting any overpayment issues is to get a professional audit of your current workers’ compensation insurance policy. A professional insurance broker or consultant with experience in the lawncare industry can review your current policy, the class codes assigned to your business, and other critical factors to ensure you’re not paying more than necessary.

They can also look at your claims history, your EMR, and other risk factors to identify areas where you can improve. A professional audit can help you uncover any inaccuracies or misclassifications that might be driving up your premiums.

2. Ensure Accurate Classification and Class Codes

Make sure your business is assigned the correct class code for workers’ compensation insurance. A simple mistake in classification could be causing you to overpay significantly. Take the time to review your class code with your insurance carrier to ensure it accurately reflects the nature of your business.

If you’re unsure about which class code your business falls under, it’s worth discussing it with your broker or insurance company. Sometimes, a simple correction can reduce your premium costs substantially.

3. Improve Your Safety Record and Safety Program

Implementing an effective safety program is one of the most effective ways to lower your workers’ compensation premiums. Insurance companies place a heavy emphasis on the safety record of a business when calculating premiums. By improving your safety standards and reducing accidents, you can lower your EMR and potentially qualify for discounts.

Training your employees on proper lifting techniques, the safe use of equipment, and emergency procedures can significantly reduce workplace accidents. Regular safety inspections and maintaining a clean, hazard-free work environment can also minimize risks.

4. Monitor Your Payroll and Correct Misreporting

Accurate payroll reporting is critical in keeping your workers’ compensation premiums in check. Make sure that your payroll records are up to date and accurately reflect the number of employees you have, as well as their job classifications. Having a clear system in place for tracking payroll will help prevent overreporting or underreporting your wages.

In addition, if your business is growing and you’re hiring more employees, make sure to notify your insurance carrier of any changes. A business with fluctuating payroll needs to maintain constant communication with their insurer to ensure that premiums reflect actual payroll numbers.

5. Take Advantage of Loss Control Programs and Discounts

Many insurance carriers offer loss control programs that provide businesses with tools and resources to improve workplace safety and reduce claims. These programs might include safety training, risk assessments, or discounts on protective equipment. By taking advantage of these programs, you can improve your safety culture and lower your premiums in the process.

Additionally, if your business has been injury-free for a significant period, you may be eligible for discounts or credits. Be sure to ask your insurance carrier about available discounts and ensure that you’re taking advantage of every opportunity to reduce costs.

6. Shop Around for Better Rates

It’s always a good idea to shop around for workers' compensation insurance if you feel like your current premium is too high. Rates can vary significantly between insurance providers, so getting multiple quotes and comparing options can help you find the best rate for your business.

An experienced insurance broker who understands the lawncare industry can help you navigate the complexities of workers’ comp insurance and connect you with providers that offer competitive rates for your specific needs.

< Older Post

Newer Post >